Yes, this is something I actually heard a trainer say at a workshop I was giving overseas.
In fact, having the unique opportunity to travel the world, giving talks about working with and modifying aggressive behaviors in dogs, I've been privy to some really interesting viewpoints when it comes to dog training.
"Spitting in your dog's food to claim ownership" is another one that ranks up there in the bizarre — and appetite spoiling — category.
While it would seem obvious that urinating on a dog will not fix a resource guarding issue, there are still a plethora of erroneous recommendations being doled out as gospel online and by well-meaning dog enthusiasts.
Some of these include:
- Reaching into a dog's food bowl while they are eating so they "get used to it"
- Taking their food bowl away while they are eating so "they know you own it"
- Petting the dog while they are eating so they "get used to it"
This "advice" actually creates a lot of business for dog trainers and behavior consultants who work with resource guarding in dogs. A fair amount of my cases involving dogs who guard food bowls or other ingestible items have a history of being exposed to these annoying human attempts of well-intentioned, but ultimately doomed, proactivity.
Now, there are some dogs who habituate to these interruptions during what should be a peaceful meal time — but why risk it?